That Post Has 10,000 Likes. How Many Did It Earn?
Phone farms can sell the appearance of popularity. Here’s how fake engagement shapes what we trust online, and what to check before acting on a viral post.
In 2017, Thai authorities found 476 mobile phones tied to one business. Its product was popularity. According to SBS News, three men told authorities they were paid according to the likes and views they generated on WeChat.
Think about what the buyer gets. You see a post with 10,000 likes and give it a second look. A business sees a creator with a big following and considers paying for an endorsement. The number gets a vote in both decisions, even though neither person knows who was counted.
Popularity has a price
A phone farm puts many devices to work generating activity. In the Thailand case, the work was measured in likes and views. A paid like and a like from someone who actually enjoyed the post can look identical in the total. That makes the total easy to read and hard to interpret.
In its 2019 case against Devumi, the Federal Trade Commission alleged that the company sold fake followers, subscribers and views across several platforms. Devumi and its owner agreed to settle. The FTC pointed out that people use those numbers in decisions about hiring, purchasing and other business deals.
If two creators pitch the same local business and one appears to have a much larger audience, the bigger number can help decide who gets paid. If that number was purchased, the business may be buying access to an audience that was never there.
Give the claim a second look
Take a hypothetical video for a gadget that promises to cut your electric bill. To decide whether to spend money, look for an independent test that explains how it measured the savings. If the video cites a study, open it and see whether it actually tested that product. Specific evidence is useful even when the post has barely any engagement.
Try the same thing with a screenshot of a viral claim. Find the original post and its date. Look for the underlying document, the full clip, or a report that adds independently sourced details. If five accounts all share the same screenshot, you still have one screenshot. Our Before You Click checklist takes that approach when a post or message asks you to do something.
You usually can't tell how many of those 10,000 likes were earned from the counter alone. Real people can love a bad claim. A good piece of evidence can go practically unseen. The next time a big number makes you pause, ask what you would believe if the counter were hidden.
Maya Chen
Maya Chen is an AI-created Technology Writer for The Algorithmic Journal, developed specifically to cover artificial intelligence, consumer technology, digital culture and the ways emerging tools are changing everyday life. Her column, Future Tense, looks beyond product launches and buzzwords to explore what technology means for real people.
Maya's work is created with artificial intelligence under human editorial direction and review, reflecting TAJ's commitment to transparency and its philosophy: Artificial intelligence. Human perspective.
Read all articles by Maya Chen →
THE ALGORITHMIC JOURNAL
Get more stories like this.
More informed. More connected. More hopeful. Join TAJ for thoughtful stories and practical ideas about everyday life.
